Mario Draghi tried again a coup – because it was so nice the first time. At that time, in 2012, the President of the European Central Bank (ECB) in one alone an emergency program for government bonds pushed through. It brought him much fame because he had saved with his solo at the right time the euro before the end.
Today, two years later, he wants to a buy-back program for controversial loan packages Europe keep economy from sinking. Again, he makes it on his own. Like the time he tried with a seemingly spontaneous insertion into a well-received speech critics outmaneuver in advance.
In the Governing Council finds fault not only federal Banker Weidmann
Only his solo designed this time much harder. After Draghi late last week published the details of his plans, opposed the ECB Governing Council not only the notoriously nagging Bundesbank President Jens Weidmann against him. Weidmann fears that a purchase of junk bonds, credit risks of private banks “shifted the central bank and thus the taxpayer” on.
Draghi has issued as a target, the total assets the ECB to increase back to the level of 2012. This would represent an increase of around one trillion euros. To achieve such a volume, so afraid of the supreme federal Banker Weidmann, Draghi could be forced to buy risky securities or to pay excessive prices for credit packages.
Germany guarantees good a quarter of the ECB balance sheet
The risks would then end up in the ECB’s balance sheet and thus in the Euro-States. Germany stands for more than a quarter of the central bank balance sheet, France for at least 20 percent. So Rumor is this time the influential and yet so loyal Frenchman Christian Noyer against ECB chief
Even European governments can Draghi in his foray. – otherwise than in 2012 – so far are pretty in the rain. With the bad copies of an originally good idea is such a thing.
where Draghi tactic was initially risen again. Very surprisingly, he had made the most important central bankers meeting in Jackson Hole American mountain nest new measures against the extremely low inflation in the euro area in view. That he thus managed facts which the 24-member Governing Council could only nod, swallowing the large majority in the committee reportedly still pretty harmless.
On the merits, however, the purchase program for credit packages including bad repute ABS securities is highly controversial – “Asset-backed securities” (ABS) are securities in which a bunch of different loans infected, about loans to SMEs or homebuyers
Even the five directors, so to speak, together with Draghi the ECB’s Executive Board should, have not been closed in September after the plan of the boss. The concern that the central bank could invite too many difficult to calculate risks on the balance sheet that she buys bad loans en masse is quite common.
Noyer against deposed by the ECB President
that’s not all: In the recent Council meeting last week, now another front seems to have opened. The Frenchman Noyer also seems to have voted against the ABS purchases. His motivation is intended to be as the other critics another: Noyer disturbs not supposed to credit purchases per se, but on the way
The. ECB does not want to settle in the conventional way through the national central banks of the euro-system this program. Instead, should be used banks or other external service providers. In the Euro-Tower one attributes this to the lack of experience of the national central banks in the ABS market. That’s why, at least initially, outside help
Noyer but is not the only one behind it suspects another calculus., The ECB wants sovereignty over the program not delegate but retain the reins in his hand.
Now the turf wars between the ECB and the national central banks is basically as old as the Euro-system itself. Governors are always anxious to keep as many tasks and let the central minimum.
But now this discussion comes at a at least in Germany debate how much power should be concentrated in the executive suite of the Euro-Towers. A question that could also move into the center of the hearing before the European Court of Justice if there negotiated next week over the government bond program OMT.
It is precisely the EU Commission and the European Parliament make it strong to hold the judicial review of the ECB extremely slim – which would mean that the central bank would be independent not only within its mandate, but also could decide more or less autonomously, as far reaches of this mandate.
ECB beyond its mandate?
For critics of Germany, the ECB moved with their new credit purchases again outside its mandate. Hans-Werner Sinn, President of Ifo Institute, the federal government called for resistance to it on – and urged citizens to, failing to pull pre Karlsruhe Constitutional Court
In fact, the enthusiasm in Berlin is currently not large. Draghi as its 2012 euro bailout program announced he had assured himself nor the backing of German Chancellor Angela Merkel. They promptly turned public behind Draghi and Weidmann dropped its critics in the back. This time it is different. Not only did applause from Berlin forthcoming: German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble complained even publicly that he was “not happy” about the purchase of securitized loans
Draghi. should not overburden the mandate of the ECB, according to German government circles. If sailing very close to the border of the permissible. More liquidity also increases the risk for new price bubbles. And do not forget you in Berlin, just like those structured securities that Draghi now wants to buy, the U.S. financial crisis have fanned as an additional accelerant. “Our concern is that the central bank piling up new long-term risks.” Seldom has it been so clear.
Chairman of the Union sees Draghi miscast
Clearly, Hans Michel Bach, chairman of the Union of the Finance Committee. “The former investment banker Draghi has learned nothing as ECB chief,” he grumbles. “Draghi was and is at his post miscast.” He makes the ECB becoming the junk Bank.
where Draghi had the finance ministers subliminally offered a kind of solidarity. The ECB could buy relatively risky loan packages and strapped banks thus relieve the more, signaled the central bank president – but only if governments or development banks whose failure would make appropriate guarantees. But that idea fell on infertile ground: not only the federal government was against the French government refused to Draghi’s suggestion
To the credit program is now quite. trimmed there. Most economists do not expect the ECB to buy up a large enough volume to really support the economy and to drive the currently paltry inflation upwards. Already there is speculation whether Draghi will not soon need to load by announcing a large-scale purchase of government bonds.
If at the end only the purchase of government bonds
But this would still not equal controversial, especially in Germany. What some experts, in turn, leads to the question whether the Italians, this may prevail at all.
“There is not only a problem of effectiveness, but also a problem of political will “, it commented the renowned bonds specialist Mohamed El-Erian, who works as an adviser to the Allianz Group. The ECB has the markets assured that she was willing to do whatever is necessary – “if there is now doubt about the determination, which is a very different prospect.”
But there are other interpretations. That governments shaky countries like France with a support Draghi and with ABS guarantees hold back, could also be that they just put more on his solo efforts. Finally, it was in the Euro-crisis so again: If the government did not move, could not stand the ECB president sometime and jumped himself into the breach, because he feared that otherwise everything would get worse
So could clammy Finance Minister put it, that they must sit out the situation long enough -. hoping that Draghi sooner or later even without guarantees buys risky loans. Or just their government bonds.
No comments:
Post a Comment